Potbelly’s secret menu is not so secretly offering high quality products. If a company is going to go to the lengths to trademark its WreckⓇ sandwich, it must be onto something good.
Potbelly buys imported, high-quality meats and slices them in-house daily and also makes its chicken salad in-house daily.
Potbelly also boasts its “world famous” Potbelly Hot Peppers and it’s Potbelly Brown Mustard. It’s obvious that the details aren’t overlooked at this store that is super serious about in-house consistent, quality food.
Full List of Potbelly’s Secret Menu
Disclaimer: Potbelly menu items not available at all locations.
Lucky 7
WreckⓇ (ham, turkey, roast beef, and salami) combined with an Italian (salami, pepperoni, capicola, and mortadella) with provolone
If Don Vito Corleone was here, this would be his go-to order. Don’t cross him, or you’ll be sleeping with the fishes.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: Order by name
Wrecking Ball
A WreckⓇ (ham, turkey, roast beef, and salami) with meatballs, Swiss cheese, mayo, lettuce, and tomato
Ode to Miley Cyrus who doesn’t give two thoughts about what you think, and neither does this unapologetically tasty sandwich.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: By name
Fireball
Meatball, cheddar, chili, and hot peppers
My world is on fire, or at least my mouth is. But it’s burning in a good way. Where’s the milk?
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: By name
Cheeseburger
Meatballs, cheddar, mayo, mustard, lettuce, tomato and pickles
This ain’t your mama’s cheeseburger. This is a cheeseburger sub specific to Potbellians.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: By name
Sicilian
An Italian with meatballs, mushrooms, marinara, Provolone cheese, and hot peppers
“He who perseveres shall win,” Sicilian proverb. This knowledge has obviously not been overlooked by Potbelly.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: By name
Black and Bleu
Roast Beef, bleu cheese, lettuce and tomato
There’s nothing better than deliciously pungent blue cheese crumbles that melt in your mouth. Paired with the right slice of meat, this could be my perfect pairing sandwich.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: Limited availability
- How to Order: Order by name
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Grilled chicken, ham, and Swiss cheese
Monsieur, I will have the Chicken Cordon Blue with a side of Grey Poupon, s’il vous plait.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: Order by name
Barnyard
A WreckⓇ plus Nueske’s bacon, meatballs, mayo, lettuce and tomato
Basically you can pair the WreckⓇ with tire rubber, and it would still be pretty dang tasty.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: Order by name
Elvis
Peanut Butter, Nueske’s bacon and bananas
Seriously, if you’ve never tried this sweet and salty combination, put a fork down and go to a Potbelly right now.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: Order by name
Toasty Turkey BLT
BLT + Turkey
This is no stretch of the imagination, but it doesn’t make it any less tasty.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: Order by name
Chicken Italiano
Grilled chicken, pepperoni, provolone, and marinara sauce
Food and music both require passion, and it’s a known fact that this Italiano sandwich variation is lacking anything but passion, ma amour.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: All locations
- How to Order: Order by name
Cookie Collision Shake
Vanilla ice cream, Oreo crumble, shortbread butter cookies, and cookie garnishes
The Cookie Monster would be in cookie heaven, and I would have to say, not very safe around me. Potbelly makes this sweet cookie sandwich right in front of you when you order. No stale ice cream for me, thank you very much.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: Limited Availability
- How to Order: Order by name or list the ingredients
Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Shake
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup, peanut butter and bananas
Sometimes an oldie is a goodie, and a thousand ingredients just aren’t necessary to make good food. Words of wisdom, kids.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: Limited Availability
- How to Order: Order by name
Ice Cream Sandwich
Choice of freshly baked cookies (Oatmeal chocolate chip, sugar, chocolate brownie cookie) with vanilla ice cream in the middle
Potbelly cookies are freshly baked in each shop daily so you KNOW these dessert calories will be worth it.
- Price: Varies by location
- Where is it Available: Limited availability
- How to Order: Order by name and specify the type cookie you want
Enjoy Potbelly’s Secret Menu
Potbelly takes its corporate responsibility seriously as it helps with your nutritional needs, green initiatives and neighborhood involvement – as if you needed any other reasons to eat here. But if you do, the secret menu is a great reason to come.
And what Potbelly’s secret menu lacks in variety, it makes up for in quality, so come check this place out soon.
