Rusty Bucket Menu & Prices

Find Rusty Bucket Menu Prices & Most Popular Food Items

We’re sharing Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern menu prices. Their memorable motto on food is: “Cooking is like a dark alley. Bad things happen when you take shortcuts.”

Although the Rusty Bucket is a little more upscale than some other taverns you may have visited in the past, they still have classic tavern fare: burgers, pizza, sandwiches, and bar food.

If you’re interested in visiting a Rusty Bucket, you should read the menu guide below. It has valuable information on pricing and some suggestions on their most popular foods.



Pork Potstickers$8.99
Spinach Con Queso$8.79
Rusty Bucket Wings1 Pound$10.79
Rusty Bucket Wings2 Pounds$20.29
Double Stacked Quesadilla$11.79
Bucket O' Shrimp$10.99
Chicken Fingers$10.99
Bucket Bites$9.79
Deep-Fried Pickles$8.79

Salads + Soups

Bucket Trio$11.49
Soup and Salad Combo$9.49
Double Nickel Salad$5.99
House Salad$5.79
Taco Salad$12.99
Wedge of Iceberg$5.99
Chicken Nickel Salad$11.99
BBQ Chopped Chicken Salad$11.99
Blackened Salmon Salad$13.79
Texas Sirloin Chili$5.99
French Onion Soup$5.99


The Reuben$9.99
Italian Torpedo$10.49
Asian Tuna Wrap$11.49
Turkey Club$10.79
Philly Cheesesteak$10.99
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich$10.99

Main Plates

Gorgonzola Sirloin$17.29
Macaroni 'n Cheese$10.99
Pesto Chicken Pasta$13.79
Baja Fish Tacos$13.99
Chicken Parmesan$14.49
Pan-Seared Salmon$18.99
Fish 'n Chips$13.49
Backyard BBQ Ribs$20.99


All burgers are served with crispy, seasoned fries or substitute sweet potato fries for $1.39 whole wheat bun available upon request.
Rusty Bucket Burger$10.49
Double Bacon Cheddar Burger$11.79
Patty Melt$11.49
Green Chili Burger$11.49
Beer Cheese Burger$11.79
Veggie Burger$10.29
Turkey Burger$10.79


The Big Sicilian$13.49
Pepperoni and Peppers$11.79


Choose any three sides.
Cuban Rice and Beans$7.79
Sweet Potato Fries$7.79
French Fries$7.79
Apple Sauce$7.79
Sticky Rice$7.79
Cottage Cheese$7.79
Macaroni and Cheese$7.79
Tomato Cucumber Salad$7.79
Roasted Carrots$7.79
Fresh Fruit Salad$7.79
Cole Slaw$7.79
Broccoli Florets$7.79

Kids' Menu

Mac 'n Cheese$4.95
Grilled Cheese$4.95
PB & J$3.95
Kids' Fish 'n Chips$4.95
Kids' Grilled Fish$4.95
Kids' Pizza6"$5.15
Kids' Veggie Pizza6"$4.99
Kids' Hot Dog$3.65
Kids' Burger$4.00
Kids' Chicken Fingers$3.75
Kids' Grilled Chicken Fingers$4.15


Note: these items may vary from day to day.
Monday: Gary's 3-Way$11.99
Tuesday: Pale Ale BBQ Pork$9.99
Wednesday: Beef Stroganoff$15.79
Thursday: Spaghetti 'n Meatballs$12.49
Friday: Shrimp Scampi$15.79
Saturday: Pork Schnitzel$15.49
Sunday: Bucket Hot Brown$11.99

Daily Drink Specials

Moscow Mule Monday$5.69
Daiquiri Tuesday$6.39
Whiskey Wednesday$6.99
Throwback Thursday$5.99
Martini Night$5.79
Gary's Famous Margaritas$6.59
Bloody Sunday$6.89

Blue Plate Specials

Gary's 3-Way$11.99
BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich$9.99
Beef Stroganoff$14.59
Spaghetti ‘n Meatballs$12.99
Shrimp Scampi$13.49
Pork Schnitzel$14.99
Bucket Hot Brown$10.99
Monday: Gary’s 3-Way$11.99
Tuesday: Pale Ale BBQ Pork$9.99
Wednesday: Beef Stroganoff$15.79
Thursday: Spaghetti 'n Meatballs$12.49
Friday: Shrimp Scampi$15.79
Saturday: Pork Schnitzel$15.49
Sunday: Bucket Hot Brown$11.99


Root Beer Float$4.99
Sticky Bun Bread Pudding$6.29
Triple Chocolate Cake$6.49


Rogue Draft Root Beer$4.19
Raspberry Lemonade$3.49
Strawberry Agua Fresca$3.49
Black and Blue Iced Tea$3.49

Popular Menu Items

The Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern is a place where people gather to hang out, have a few drinks, and eat great food. They have an extensive drink menu and a wide variety of food options.

One of the coolest features at “The Bucket” is that they have a daily Blue Plate Special every day of the week that features classic meals like spaghetti and meatballs, shrimp scampi, and a turkey dinner, available all day at great prices.

Start your meal with a few of the Rusty Bucket’s appetizers, from hummus to hot spinach dip to deep fried pickles (a bar favorite!). After that, you can try out eight different sandwiches, seven varieties of burger, or one of their many “Main Plates” like meatloaf or BBQ ribs. And don’t forget dessert!

Here are some of The Bucket’s most popular items to try:

The Big Sicilian

If you’re in the mood for pizza, then this pie should be calling your name. All of the Rusty Bucket’s pizzas are made on 12”, artisan hand-tossed crust. The Big Sicilian adds red sauce with mozzarella and provolone cheese and then tops it with pepperoni, Italian sausage, capicola, and red onions. This is a perfect pie to share or take whatever you can’t eat by yourself home.

Baja Fish Tacos

Fish tacos have become very popular over the last decade and the Rusty Bucket knows how to do them right. They take blackened fish and top it with fresh citrus cabbage cole slaw, sour cream, and fresh cilantro.

Double Stacked Quesadilla

This quesadilla may be considered an appetizer, but it also eats like a meal. You get blackened chicken, cheddar and pepperjack cheeses, black bean and corn salsa. It comes served with sides of sour cream, guacamole, and salsa.

BBQ Chopped Chicken Salad

This Bucket favorite features pulled, oven-roasted chicken served over mixed greens. It comes with tortilla strips, black beans, tomatoes, and pepper jack cheese on top and it’s all tossed in a ranch dressing and drizzled with BBQ sauce.

The Rusty Bucket’s History

Gary Callicoat founded Rusty Bucket in 2002. He had a vision to create a restaurant that had friendly service in a relaxed setting. His career started in the industry when he was just 15 years old as a dishwasher. He eventually moved into operation roles within Cameron Mitchell Restaurants.

Under Mitchell’s guidance, Gary opened the first Rusty Bucket in Dublin, Ohio. Since then restaurant has grown to over 20 locations. Aside from serving great food and drinks, The Bucket is committed to supporting the communities it does business in.